Storytelling Offers Happier Ending for Stroke Victim
Author: Jane Glenn Haas
Five years after a massive stroke and befuddling stroke, Shirley Porus is remembering.
“Is this me?” she asked in wonder when she picked up a book of her poems just three months ago. She had no memory of writing the words. But today, she recalls a bit here, a disconnected piece there- maybe not everything but at least something about writing the poems, the songs, and the children’s books. She remembers because her husband, Marcus, patiently told her stories, over and over again. Stories about anniversaries, anecdotes about birthday parties, tales of family gatherings. He linked her written words to her past through storytelling, and the technique worked. “When they read to me, then in all comes back,” Shirley, 78, says. “They tell me the story and I remember. I may not say it, but I remember it.”
Using storytelling to jog memories is a new buzz, a strategy for caregivers who want to bring the past into the present for brain-damaged patients. In California, at least 1.4 million people impaired by head trauma, stroke, dementia. Stroke patients are more inclined to lose physical abilities than memory, says Dr. Steven Cramer, neurologist at UCI Medical Center. “But those that do lose memory rarely regain it,” he says, adding that too often family and medical experts give up on stroke patients, limiting their recovery potential.
People with head trauma have different outcome potentials, he says. For example, a brain-damaged middle-age farmer in “The Drawer Boy,” which runs through June 29 on the Main Stage at South Coast Repertory, regains memories when he sees his past life in a play. In this case, art is mirroring reality, says Karen Brennan, a creative writer professor at the University of Utah. She used a similar technique to aid her daughter’s recovery from a major brain injury eight years ago. Her experience is chronicled in “Being With Rachel: A story of Memory and Survival” (Norton 2002).
As Rachel lay in a coma for four months, Brennan sat beside her, telling stories. When Rachel regained consciousness- but had no short-term memory-Brennan spent hours telling her daughter tales about her past because she believes there is a link to a person’s ability to absorb stories and short-term memory. Today, Rachel is 32, “still struggles with short-term memory although she is much better,” Brennan says.
As “The Drawer Boy” program notes, memories are made deep inside the brain in a structure known as the hippocampus and stored in the outer part of the brain, or cortex.
Shirley’s stroke Nov. 11, 1998, robbed her of speech and movement. More, it left her with empty pages in her brain. Despite quick action by her husband in calling paramedics, regardless of swift emergency room response including “clot buster drugs,” Shirley had aphasia, a communication impairment from stroke that affects the ability to speak and write. She worked with physical and speech therapists. Slowly, she regained some physical abilities. But Marcus refused to give up on his wife of 65 years. They moved from their Fountain Valley home, the place they moved to from Chicago in 1993, to a smaller single-floor home in Huntington Beach. “This is just a new, great adventure,” Marcus told Shirley as he encouraged her improvements. Care giving, he admits, “is a tough job, but if you love someone, you make up your mind you have to do it and somehow, you do it.” In February, Marcus and the couple’s son, graphic designer Stephen Marcus, put together a book of Shirley’s writings- poems for special occasions, children’s books and songs. “Is that really me?” she asked as she saw the pages, a question that became the book’s title.
Marcus persisted on helping her remember. He talked about his 75th birthday party. He read her poem to him: “Happy birthday, dear Marcus, you’re one of a kind…” He sand her songs, “When life is hard and things look bad, your troubles make you fell so sad, just straighten up and start to sing about all the good that life can bring.”
A few weeks ago, Shirley asked to read the book. And she began correcting the typos, the misspelled words, and the punctuation. “Her therapists were floored,” Marcus says. Only months later, his wife sat in front of the computer and cried. Her hand wouldn’t move on the keyboard. Today Shirley grins. “I wrote the words. He says I did. I remember.”
Is storytelling a unique way to prompt memory? Cramer is not sure. “Anything that cues the brain, that improves the environment, is always better.” Of course, recovery also depends on the amount of damage, he says. Cramer equates the brain to”big string of fatty, wet spaghetti,” creating many sites of small damage. “Think of is as maybe destroying every fifth lawn in Costa Mesa,” Cramer says. A stroke, by compassion, “could destroy all of Costa Mesa or even everything along Interstate 5. “Some people have small losses, others must be institutionalized. It depends on what breaks inside.”
Shirley says the worst loss for her is independence: “Being able to go out and do as I please, so what are you going to do?” Then Marcus reminds her they do go out. At least every other day they go somewhere, he says. Maybe a restaurant, an evening with friends or even a play. And they laugh a lot. He labels her garbled words “Shirley talk.” “Once you can start laughing about it, it gets easier,” Marcus says. “Make her laugh. That’s one thing I can do.” Shirley grins. “Make me laugh. I love to laugh. Makes me happy.”
Source: The Orange County Register, Wednesday, June 18, 2003
American Stroke Foundation
Giving to AHF
Talk to an Aphasia Professional